Friday, July 18, 2014

The Internet and Tests

I had never previously considered allowing students to use the internet during tests. It is when issues like this are raised that I begin to think that my high school was a long time ago (realistically, it was ten years ago). Since we did not have a computer with internet for every student as they do now, I'm left to speculate on the utility of it based on these articles. One of the best ideas expressed for the pro side relates to the need for tests to move beyond fact recall. I agree with the authors that this is not the purpose of learning, and it's more important to test what the students can do with their knowledge rather than merely test whether or not they have dates and facts memorized. Perhaps with access to facts via the internet, we can move our tests beyond fact recall. We can test students on their interpretation of those facts, and ask them what the significance of the facts is. On the other side of the argument, the author correctly points out that the internet may not be usable for every classroom. For instance, math is a subject where the internet would just give students the answers rather than force them to interpret data. Other classrooms have the problem of having too wide a range of students to be able to ask them all to use higher level thinking. Some students have not developed to this level, so they will struggle on the test even with the computer. Ultimately, the case made for allowing internet usage during tests won me over. It's true that classes contain students of varying developmental levels and that testing them is difficult; however, this is not something new nor is it exacerbated by allowing internet usage.The internet is a tool that students are accustomed to using everyday. Using it to look up facts whether for a test or not is natural for them. Problems with allowing students to look up facts on the internet during tests only arise when the tests are so simplistic as to merely solicit basic information. In my classrooms, I intend to allow the students to do research on the internet during tests. I don't intend on testing them on fact recall. In fact, I would much prefer to use essays that dig deep into an issue and require critical thinking rather than testing them on data, and the internet is an excellent tool for testing students in this manner. Whether or not the students use their cell phones instead of school computers with filters is not of concern to me. I don't believe in much censorship anyway, and students are able to use their phones at any time of the day and do whatever they want on the internet. Filtering the internet for students doesn't really serve much purpose in my opinion, so the author's argument against internet usage during tests because they can use their uncensored phones does not hold much weight. At this point in my career, I am excited about the opportunity that the internet brings for my classroom.

2 comments:

  1. Justin
    I liked reading your blog on the issue of whether or not internet should be used during testing. Even though I don't agree with everything you have to say, I liked reading about your opinion on the topic. I think that we are both in agreement on having the tests that teachers are making be more than testing basic facts. I remember you saying you are interested in teaching at the high school level. This is particularly important for high schoolers because they are learning more in depth concepts. It seems to me that if you were to allow your students to use the internet in your classroom during tests you would have it under control. The fact that you are excited to use it and don't have many concerns about censorship is probably a good thing because if I used it I would be too worried about monitoring my students. I like that you have a positive outlook on this new issue. Maybe my perspective will become more like yours when I start to teach. Even though I don't want my students to use the internet while they are testing, I am not against trying it out one or two times.
    -Meredith

    ReplyDelete
  2. I had a whole comment typed out for you, but Blogger deleted it. :/ Let me try this again.

    I agree with you about the censorship. It's a silly thing to have. How will students learn if they don't make mistakes? Putting up barriers only leads to finding way around barriers instead of understanding WHY.

    Also, in respect to using the internet, I know we have had an indirect discussion between our blogs about how we think the same thing. This internet thing is exciting! Like you, I didn't have very much internet access in school. At the University level, however, almost all of my tests and quizzes were online. Of course, you have access to the internet when you're taking a quiz on Moodle. However, those questions were thought provoking questions that you can't Google verbatim.

    ReplyDelete